APSIM玉米模型中辐射估算的误差传输

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-6362.2017.10.002

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 以华北地区3个典型站点（山东省莒县站、河南省郑州和南阳站）为研究对象，分析计算玉米生长期间Angstrom-Prescott模型、Ogelman模型、Bahel模型、日照百分率和气温日较差综合模型（简称综合模型）和刘可群等太阳总辐射估算模型的相对误差，分别将该5个模型估算结果和太阳辐射实测值（依次命名为模拟方案1-5和模拟方案0）输入APSIM玉米模型，计算各模型驱动APSIM玉米模型模拟产量的相对误差，分析由于太阳辐射估算误差对模型产量模拟结果造成的误差传输。结果表明，5个日太阳辐射模型在生长期内的平均估算误差（εi）在莒县站以A-P模型最小，在郑州和南阳站点以综合模型最小；各辐射估算模型对APSIM模型的产量模拟结果均有明显影响，综合模型模拟结果最好，其驱动APSIM模拟的玉米产量误差最小；5个辐射模型估算误差对APSIM模型模拟玉米产量的误差均有放大效应，Angstrom-Prescott模型、Ogelman模型、Bahel模型、综合模型和刘可群等模型辐射误差分别以2.23、2.28、1.63、1.85、1.90倍传输到APSIM玉米模型模拟的产量误差，可见，一定要重视辐射模型的选取和辐射模型经验系数的确定；评价5个辐射模型的误差传输到产量的误差，要综合考虑辐射模型本身的误差和辐射误差传输到产量误差中放大的效应两方面的影响，综合模型传输到产量的误差最小。因此，在华北地区无太阳总辐射实测值的地区使用APSIM模型时，本研究推荐辐射方案4即综合模型为首选模型。

关键词: 太阳辐射模型, 作物模型, 模拟误差, 误差传输, 华北地区

Abstract: Taking three typical maize land sites in North China (Juxian station in Shandong province, Zhengzhou and Nanyang stations in Henan province) as the research objects, the effects of radiation models on crop yield simulation were investigated. Five radiation models, including the Angstrom-Prescott (A-P) model, Ogelman model, the Bahel model, the comprehensive model of sunshine duration and diurnal temperature range model (referred to as the comprehensive model), and Liu’s model (followed by simulation scheme 1-5) , were used to simulate the total solar radiation and validated against measurement (simulation scheme 0). The radiation results of the five models were further utilized to drive APSIM model to simulate the maize yield. The results showed that the estimated errors（εi）of A-P model was the smallest in the Juxian station, and that of the comprehensive model was the smallest in Zhengzhou and Nanyang stations. Different radiation estimation models had significantly different effects on yield simulation results of APSIM model, scheme 4 rendered the best result. The radiation errors brought by the five radiation models had enlarged the final results of maize yield simulated by APSIM model. The propagation error transferred to APSIM maize model simulation yield was 2.23, 2.28, 1.63, 1.85, 1.90 for the A-P model, the Ogelman model, the Bahel model, the comprehensive model, and the Liu’s model, respectively. It is obvious that the selection of the radiation model and the empirical coefficient of the radiation model should be taken into full consideration; with regard to the errors of crop yield simulation caused by radiation models two factors should be taken into account: the errors of the five radiation models and these errors transmitted to the crop model with augmentation. Generally speaking, Scheme 4 has the smallest error compared with other schemes. Therefore it was recommended to use scheme 4 to drive APSIM model in the absence of field measured radiation.

Key words: Solar radiation model, Crop model, Simulation errors, Errors transmission, Northern China Plain

毛洋洋，赵艳霞，张祎，胡正华，魏亮. APSIM玉米模型中辐射估算的误差传输[J]. 中国农业气象, 2017, 38(10): 632-643.

MAO Yang-yang, ZHAO Yan-xia, ZHANG Yi, HU Zheng-hua, WEI Liang. Errors Transmission of Radiation Estimation in APSIM Maize Model[J]. Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology, 2017, 38(10): 632-643.

参考文献

[1] 李秉柏,马新明,徐立华.棉花干物质积累的模拟模型与检验[J].中国农业气象,1998,19(2):20-24. Li B B,Ma X M,Xu L H.Simulation model and validation of dry matter accumulation of cotton[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology,1998,19(2):20-24.(in Chinese) [2] 何洪林,于贵瑞,牛栋.复杂地形条件下的太阳资源辐射计算方法研究[J].资源科学,2003,25(1):78-85. He H L,Yu G R,Niu D.Method of global solar radiation calculation on complex territories[J].Resources Science,2003, 25(1):78-85.(in Chinese) [3] Almorox J,Hontoria C.Global solar radiation estimation using sunshine duration in Spain[J].Energy Conversion and Management,2004,45(9-10):1529-1535. [4] Hunt L A,Kuchar L,Swanton C J.Estimation of solar radiation for use in crop modeling[J].Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 1998,91(3-4):293-300. [5] Podesta G P,Nunez L,Villanueva C A,et al.Estimating daily solar radiation in the Argentine Pampas[J].Agricultural and Forest Meteorology,2004,123(1-2):41-53. [6] 刘建栋,于强,金之庆,等.冬小麦叶片光合作用农业气象数学模型研究[J].中国农业气象,2003,24(1):22- 25. Liu J D,Yu Q,Jin Z Q,et al.Study on an agrometeorological model to simulate the leaf photosynthesis of winter wheat in Huanghuaihai Region[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology, 2003,24(1):22-25.(in Chinese) [7] Hoogenboom G.Contribution of agrometeorology to the simulation of crop production and its applications[J]. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology,2000, 103(1-2):137-157. [8] Prescott J A.Evaporation from a water surface in relation to solar radiation[J].Transactions of the Royal Society of South Australia,1940,64(1940):114-118. [9] Yang K,Koike T,Ye B S.Improving estimation of hourly,daily, and monthly solar radiation by importing global data sets[J]. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology,2006,137(1): 43-55. [10] Almorox J Y,Hontoria C.Global solar radiation estimation using sunshine duration in Spain[J].Energy Conversion and Management,2004,45(9):1529-1535. [11] Chen R S,Ersi K,Yang J P,et al.Validation of five global radiation models with measured daily data in China[J].Energy Conversion and Management,2004,45(11-12):1759-1769. [12] 刘可群,陈正洪,梁益同,等.日太阳总辐射推算模型[J].中国农业气象,2008,29(1):16-19. Liu K Q,Chen Z H,Liang Y T,et al.Calculation model for daily global solar radiation[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology, 2008,29(1):16-19.(in Chinese) [13] 毛洋洋,赵艳霞,张祎,等.五个常见日太阳总辐射模型在华北地区的有效性验证及分析[J].中国农业气象,2016,37(5): 520-530. Mao Y Y,Zhao Y X,Zhang Y,et al.Validation and analysis of five general daily solar radiation estimation models used in Northern China[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology, 2016,37(5):520-530.(in Chinese) [14] 戴明宏,陶洪斌,廖树华,等.基于CERES-Maize模型的华北平原玉米生产潜力的估算与分析[J].农业工程学报,2008, (4):30-36. Dai M H,Tao H B,Liao S H,et al.Estimation and analysis of maize potential productivity based on CERES- Maize model in the North China Plain[J].Transactions of the CSAE,2008, (4):30-36.(in Chinese) [15] 刘伟昌,张雪芬,余卫东,等.水稻高温热害风险评估方法研究[J].气象与环境科学,2009,(1):33-38. Liu W C,Zhang X F,Yu W D,et al.Assessment method study on high temperature damage to rick[J].Meteorological and Environmental Sciences,2009,(1):33-38. [16] 陈思宁,赵艳霞,申双和.基于集合卡尔曼滤波的PyWOFOST模型在东北玉米估产中的适用性验证[J].中国农业气象, 2012,33(2):245-253. Chen S N,Zhao Y X,Shen S H.Applicability of Py WOFOST model based on ensemble kalmanfilter in simulating maize yield in Northeast China[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology, 2012,33(2):245-253.(in Chinese) [17] 栾庆祖,叶彩华,莫志鸿,等.基于WOFOST模型的玉米干旱损失评估:以北京为例[J].中国农业气象,2014,35(3):311-316. Luan Q Z,Ye C H,Mo Z H,et al.Maize yield loss assessment for drought based on WOFOST model:a case study in Beijing[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology,2014,35(3): 311-316. [18] Chen C,Wang E,Yu Q.Modelling the effects of climate variability and water management on crop water productivity and water balance in the North China Plain[J].Agricultural Water Management,2010,97(8):1175-1184. [19] Chen C,Baethgen W E,Wang E,et al.Characterizing spatial and temporal variability of crop yield caused by climate and irrigation in the North China Plain[J].Theoretical and Applied Climatology,2011,106(3-4):365-381. [20] Xiao D,Tao F.Contributions of cultivars, management and climate change to winter wheat yield in the North China Plain in the past three decades[J].European Journal of Agronomy,2014,52:112-122. [21] 王娜,王靖,冯利平,等.华北平原冬小麦-夏玉米轮作区采用“两晚”技术的产量效应模拟分析[J].中国农业气象,2015, 36(5):611-618. Wang N,Wang J,Feng L P,et al.Modeling the impact of “double-delay” technology on yield of wheat-maize cropping system in the North China Plain[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology,2015,36(5):611-618.(in Chinese) [22] Asseng S,Van Keulen H,Stol W.Performance and application of the APSIM N-wheat model in the Netherlands[J]. European Journal of Agronomy,2000,12(1):37-54. [23] Wang E,Robertson M J,Hammer G L,et al.Development of a generic crop model template in the cropping system model APSIM[J].European Journal of Agronomy,2002,18(1):121-140. [24] McCown R L,Hammer G L,Hargreaves J N G,et al.APSIM:a novel software system for model development, model testing and simulation in agricultural systems research[J]. Agricultural Systems,1996,50(3):255-271. [25] Keating B A,Carberry P S,Hammer G L,et al.An overview of APSIM,a model designed for farming systems simulation [J].European Journal of Agronomy,2003,18(3/4):267-288. [26] Wang E,Robertson M J,Hammer G L,et al.Development of a generic crop model template in the cropping system model APSIM[J].European Journal of Agronomy,2002,18(1/2): 121-140. [27] Asseng S,Anderson G C,Dunin F X,et al.Use of the APSIM wheat model to predict yield,drainage,and NO3-leaching for a deep sand[J].Crop and Pasture Science,1997,49(3):363-378. [28] Asseng S,Fillery I R P,Dunin F X,et al.Potential deep drainage under wheat crops in a Mediterranean climate I:temporal and spatial variability[J].Crop and Pasture Science,2001,52(1):45-56. [29] Wu D,Yu Q,Lu C,et al.Quantifying production potentials of winter wheat in the North China Plain[J].European Journal of Agronomy,2006,24(3):226-235. [30] Wang E,Cresswell H,Paydar Z,et al.Opportunities for manipulating catchment water balance by changing vegetation type on a topographic sequence:a simulation study[J]. Hydrological Processes,2008,22(6):736 -749. [31] Robertson M J,Carberry P S,Huth N I,et al.Simulation of growth and development of diverse legume species in APSIM[J].Crop and Pasture Science,2002,53(4):429-446. [32] Bassu S,Asseng S,Motzo R,et al.Optimising sowing date of durum wheat in a variable mediterranean environment[J]. Field Crops Research,2009,111(1):109-118. [33] 刘志娟,王晓光,王静,等.APSIM玉米模型在东北地区的适应性[J].作物学报,2012,38(4):740-746. Liu Z J,Wang X J,Wang J,et al.Adaptability of APSIM Maize Model in Northeast China[J].Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2012,38(4):740-746.(in Chinese) [34] Li K,Yang X,Liu Z,et al.Low yield gap of winter wheat in the North China Plain[J].European Journal of Agronomy, 2014,59:1-12. [35] Anderson W,Johansen C,Siddique K H M.Addressing the yield gap in rainfed crops:a review[J].Agronomy for Sustainable Development,2016,36(1):1-13. [36] 王琳,郑有飞,于强,等.APSIM模型对华北平原小麦-玉米连作系统的适用性[J].应用生态学报,2007,(11):2480-2486. Wang L,Zheng Y F,Yu Q,et al.Applicability of agricultural production systems simulator (APSIM) in simulating the production and water use of wheat-maize continuous cropping system in North China Plain[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2007,(11):2480-2486.(in Chinese) [37] 陈超,于强,王恩利,等.华北平原作物水分生产力区域分异规律模拟[J].资源科学,2009,31(9):1477-1485. Chen C,Yu Q,Wang E L,et al.Modeling the spatial distribution of crop water productivity in the North China Plain[J].Resources Science,2009,31(9):1477-1485.(in Chinese) [38] Chen C,Wang E,Yu Q.Modelling the effects of climate variability and water management on crop water productivity and water balance in the North China Plain[J].Agricultural Water Management,2010,97(8):1175-1184. [39] 谈美秀,王靖,余卫东,等.基于统计和过程模型的河南省夏玉米最适播种期时空分布特征[J].应用生态学报,2015, 26(12):3670-3678. Tan M X,Wang J,Yu W D,et al.Temporal and spatial variation of the optimal sowing dates of summer maize based on both statistical and processes models in Henan Province,China[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2015, 26(12):3670-3678.(in Chinese) [40] Wang C L,Yue T X.Solar radiation climatology calculation in China[J].Journal of Resources and Ecology,2014,5(2): 132-138. [41] Zhou J,Wang Y Z,Yang G.General formula for estimation of monthly average daily global solar radiation in China[J]. Energy Conversion and Management,2005,46(2):257-268. [42] Allen R G,Pereira L S,Raes D,et al.Crop evapotranspiration [M].FAO Irrigation and Drainage,1998:56. [43] 魏合理,徐青山,张天舒.用GMS-5气象卫星遥测地面太阳总辐射[J].遥感学报,2003,7(6):466-471. Wei H L,Xu Q S,Zhang T S.Observation of solar irradiance at the surface from GMS-5[J].Journal of Remote Sensing, 2003,7(6):466-471.(in Chinese) [44] 童成立,张文菊,汤阳,等.逐日太阳辐射的模拟计算[J].中国农业气象,2005,26(3):165-169. Tong C L,Zhang W J,Tang Y,et al.Estimation of daily solar radiation in China[J].Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology, 2005,26(3):165-169.(in Chinese) [45] 戴彤,王靖,赫迪,等.1961-2010年气候变化对西南冬小麦潜在和雨养产量影响的模拟分析[J].中国生态农业学报, 2016,(3):293-305. Dai T,Wang J,He D,et al.Impact simulation of climate change on potential and rainfed yields of winter wheat in Southwest China from 1961 to 2010[J].Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture,2016,(3):293-305.(in Chinese) [46] 张延,任小川,赵英,等.未来气候变化对关中地区冬小麦耗水和产量的影响模拟[J].干旱地区农业研究,2016,(1): 220-228. Zhang Y,Ren X C,Zhao Y,et al.Impact and simulation of climate change on water consumption and yield of winter- wheat in Guanzhong Region[J].Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas,2016,(1):220-228.(in Chinese) [47] 毛飞,赵玉金,孙涵,等.1961-2010年中国Angstrom-Prescott系数时空变化特征[J].气象与环境科学, 2016,(1):43-51. Mao F,Zhao Y J,Sun H,et al.Spatial and temporal change characteristics of Angstrom-Prescott coefficients in China in 1961-2010[J].Meteorological and Environmental Science, 2016,(1):43-51.(in Chinese)