中国农业气象 ›› 2024, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (03): 257-267.doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-6362.2024.03.004

• 农业生态环境栏目 • 上一篇    下一篇

养殖尾水混合不同比例水溶肥种植水培生菜的综合效益评价

杨小玲,李招,程艳茹,修维宁,刘阳,战博   

  1. 1.重庆市农业科学院,重庆 401329;2.农业废弃物资源化利用重庆市重点实验室,重庆 401329;3.农业农村部西南山地智慧农业技术重点实验室(部省共建),重庆 401329;4.重庆市南岸区农业农村委员会,重庆 401336
  • 收稿日期:2023-09-15 出版日期:2024-03-20 发布日期:2024-03-13
  • 作者简介:杨小玲,E-mail:675345186@qq.com
  • 基金资助:
    国家重点研发计划项目“绿色高效智能水产养殖工厂创制与应用”(2022YFD2001700);2021年度三峡后续工作科研项目(5000002021BF50001);重庆市技术创新与应用发展专项重点项目(cstc2020jscx-tpyzxX0001);重庆市技术创新与应用发展专项“鱼菜共生智能工厂关键技术及装备研发”(CSTB2022TIAD-ZXX0053)

Comprehensive Benefit Evaluation of Hydroponic Lettuce Planted on Aquaculture Wastewater Mixed with Different Proportions of Water-soluble Fertilizer

YANG Xiao-ling, LI Zhao, CHENG Yan-ru, XIU Wei-ning, LIU Yang, ZHAN Bo   

  1. 1.Chongqing Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Chongqing 401329, China;2.Chongqing Key Laboratory of Agricultural Waste Resource Utilization, Chongqing 401329;3.Southwest Mountain Smart Agricultural Technology Key Laboratory(Co-construction by the Ministry and Province), Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, Chongqing 401329;4.Chongqing Nan 'an District Agricultural and Rural Committee, Chongqing 401336
  • Received:2023-09-15 Online:2024-03-20 Published:2024-03-13

摘要: 以“奶油生菜”为研究对象,将不同量的山崎配方水溶肥溶于工厂化养鱼尾水,配制成混合营养液,进行营养液膜栽培(NFT)水培生菜实验,以期筛选出最佳水肥配比,为实现工厂化养鱼尾水资源化利用提供理论依据。实验设置5个处理,分别为S1(123g水溶肥+150L养鱼尾水)、S2(98.4g水溶肥+150L养鱼尾水)、S3(73.8g水溶肥+150L养鱼尾水)、S4(49.2g水溶肥+150L养鱼尾水)、S5(24.6g水溶肥+150L养鱼尾水),以CK(123g水溶肥+150L清水)作为对照,探究不同处理对生菜产量和品质的影响。采用基于熵权法的TOPSIS综合效益评价模型分析确定最佳水肥配比参数。结果表明,混合营养液能提高生菜对水肥的吸收量,但随水溶肥浓度增加,生菜耗肥量呈先增大后减小的趋势;不同处理下生菜耗水耗肥量均低于CK处理,S1−S5处理相比CK处理分别节肥25.01%、19.15%、34.12%、51.89%和74.10%。混合营养液能有效促进生菜生长,但生菜各项生长指标均随水溶肥浓度上升呈先增大后减少的趋势,S2处理下生菜产量最高,为1.88kg·m−2,相比CK处理增加15.32%。此外,混合营养液可提高生菜品质,可溶性糖和可溶性蛋白含量呈先增大后减小的趋势,S2处理下生菜可溶性糖和可溶性蛋白含量最高;维生素C(VC)含量、硝酸盐含量均与水溶肥浓度呈正相关,S1处理下VC含量最高,S1−S5处理下硝酸盐含量均低于CK处理。综合效益评价结果表明,S2处理对生菜的生长最为有利,可以获得较高的产量并兼具较好的品质,为最佳配比,养鱼尾水与水溶肥合理配施后,可显著促进水肥吸收,提高生菜产量和品质,实现作物生产效益最佳。

关键词: 养殖废水, 水肥耦合, 生菜水培, 产量品质, 熵权法, TOPSIS

Abstract: The hydroponic lettuce experiment involved the blending of aquaculture wastewater with water-soluble fertilizer, aiming to determine the optimal ratio of water and fertilizer. This study aims to provide a theoretical foundation for effectively utilizing water resources in industrial aquaculture wastewater. In this study, the research focused on "cream lettuce" as the primary subject. Various quantities of Yamazaki formula water-soluble fertilizer were dissolved in industrial aquaculture wastewater to create a blended nutrient solution. Subsequently, an experiment utilizing the Nutrient Film Technique (NFT) was conducted to investigate its effects. The experiment consisted of five distinct treatments: S1 (123g fertilizer + 150L wastewater), S2 (98.4g fertilizer + 150L wastewater), S3 (73.8g fertilizer + 150L wastewater), S4 (49.2g fertilizer + 150L water), and S5 (24.6g fertilizer + 150L water). Additionally, a control group labeled CK (123g fertilizer + 150L water) was utilized to examine the impact of different treatments on lettuce yield and quality. The TOPSIS comprehensive benefit evaluation model, based on the entropy weight method, was employed to analyze and ascertain the optimal parameters for the water and fertilizer ratio. The results demonstrated that the mixed nutrient solution effectively enhanced the absorption of water and fertilizer. However, it was observed that as the concentration of fertilizer increased, the lettuce's fertilizer consumption exhibited an initial rise followed by a subsequent decline. The water and fertilizer consumption of lettuce under the various treatments was lower than that of the CK treatment. Furthermore, the S1-S5 treatments exhibited fertilizer savings of 25.01%, 19.15%, 34.12%, 51.89%, and 74.10% respectively, in comparison to the CK treatment. The mixed nutrient solution proved to be highly effective in promoting the growth of lettuce. However, it was observed that the growth indicators of lettuce followed a pattern of initial increase and subsequent decrease as the fertilizer concentration increased. Notably, the highest lettuce yield of 1.88 kg·m−2 was achieved under the S2 treatment, representing a 15.32% increase compared to the CK treatment. Furthermore, the mixed nutrient solution exhibited a positive impact on improving the quality of lettuce. The contents of soluble sugar and soluble protein in lettuce displayed an initial increase and subsequent decrease, with the highest levels observed in lettuce treated with S2. The content of vitamin C(VC) and nitrate exhibited a positive correlation with the fertilizer concentration. Specifically, the S1 treatment resulted in the highest VC content, while the nitrate content under the S1-S5 treatments was lower compared to the CK treatment. The comprehensive benefit evaluation revealed that the S2 treatment was the most favorable for lettuce growth, yielding higher crop output and superior quality. The optimal combination of fish tail water and fertilizer demonstrated significant benefits, enhancing water and fertilizer absorption, improving lettuce yield and quality, and maximizing overall crop production efficiency.

Key words: Aquaculture wastewater, Water-fertilizer coupling, Hydroponic lettuce, Yield and quality, Entropy method, TOPSIS